Return2PLAi
3

K · #3 · Indianapolis Colts · week 4 vs Washington Commanders · Sun Oct 4 · 9:30 AM ET

Spencer Shrader

  • ROLE a backup
  • EXP 2 seasons
  • AGE 25-28
  • DEPTH PK1
92%PLAY EXPECTED

As of week 4, Spencer Shrader was a K for IND, age 27.3, 2 seasons of experience. In 2026 through week 3 he was listed at depth rank 1 on his club's depth chart; he had played 3 games on 0% of snaps. Before 2026 he played 9 games (postseason included) over 2 seasons. His injury history held 1 episode (hamstring 1), 1 of them reaching OUT; the last was a hamstring injury in 2024 week 13.

The full read

In short

How our call moved in week 4

  • our call, P(plays)

87% EXPECTED → 92% EXPECTED

Every call we wrote for him in week 4, earliest first, as written.

In short

Spencer Shrader is a backup at placekicker for IND — 0% of the snaps in his best week of 11. He has a groin injury. His team has not listed him on the final report. We say he plays — 92%, in a band that plays 76% of the time. We have said PLAY since 68 hours before kickoff.

The reader concurs · grade B

The injury is current (groin suffered in pregame warmups Sept. 27, P3/P4), but he kicked through it the same day, going 4-for-4 including a 53-yard game winner (P3) and later all five kicks with a 58-yarder (P1).

What the read cites

What was reportedSource
1“should be good to kick in London this weekend against the Washington Commanders—although he may be on a “kick count” in team practice this week”source not recorded
2“Shrader is expected to be fine to play in the Colts' upcoming game in London.”source not recorded
3“The team may consider using punter Rigoberto Sanchez for kickoffs to manage Shrader's workload.”source not recorded
4“Indianapolis Colts kicker Spencer Shrader injured his hamstring/groin area during pregame warmups.”source not recorded
5“Indianapolis announced immediately after the opening kickoff that Shrader was questionable to return due to a groin injury.”source not recorded
The reader's full reasoning

The rest of the reading

The special teams coach, the strongest voice available, says he 'should be good to kick in London,' with only a practice 'kick count' as management (P2), and the beat writer frames him as 'expected to be fine to play' (P1), with the only contingency being Sanchez handling kickoffs to reduce workload (P1) — a workload tweak, not a replacement. Nothing in the prose contradicts the 0.870 forecast; the residual risk is simply that no official game-status designation has been issued yet.

10versions in week 4
13average, every player
54most for one player

How the call moved

EXPECTED since Thu Oct 1 · 1:10 PM ET · 68 h before kickoff. Biggest move: 87% → 92%, Thu Oct 1 · 1:22 PM ET to Thu Oct 1 · 4:00 PM ET, with no club report in between.

Our call

Injury report

Our call · week 4

NOT EXPECTEDUNLIKELYCOIN FLIPLIKELYEXPECTED

92% · EXPECTED

we expect him to play — this band plays 76% of the time (71–81%), measured out of fold. We stand behind this one.

No dated practice report for him in week 4

The team has not published one we can date, or the window has not reached it. Not the same as his having practiced.

Head start

  • Our call
  • Kickoff

The evidence behind his current call

We read the news; nothing was attributed.

Stats, with ranges — dot = his average, bar = his game range

  • Snap share0.0% range 0–0

    wk 1–11 · 11 games

Snaps by week — his larger of the offence and defence share

  1. 0%wk 1
  2. 0%wk 2
  3. 0%wk 3
  4. 0%wk 4
  5. 0%wk 5
  6. 0%wk 6
  7. 0%wk 7
  8. 0%wk 8
  9. 0%wk 9
  10. 0%wk 10
  11. 0%wk 11

Missed while on the injury report

SeasonWeeks on the reportMissed while listed
202610

Only the weeks he was on the injury report with a recorded result — not every game of his career.

Medical history

WhenInjuryWeeks on a reportWorst status
2026 · wk 4groin1—
2024 · wk 13right hamstring1Out

Every injury episode on file for him, as the record holds it.

Injury history by season · 2 episodes · 2 weeks on a report

  • ruled out
  • listed, and played

Each bar is one episode: the week it began and how many weeks he was on a report, coloured by the worst status.

The rest of his team's report in week 4

PlayerPosPracticeWhose wordCallChance he playsBand
Keenan AllenWRDNPoursCOIN FLIPleans play56%COIN FLIP
Mo Alie-CoxTEFULLoursPLAY85%LIKELY
Grover StewartDTFULLoursPLAY87%EXPECTED
Charvarius WardCBFULLoursPLAY90%EXPECTED
Ashton DulinWRFULLoursPLAY87%EXPECTED
Jonathan TaylorRBFULLoursPLAY90%EXPECTED
Akeem Davis-GaitherLBFULLoursPLAY91%EXPECTED

The model reads the room: who else is out shifts what his own designation is worth.

The evidence behind his earlier calls

The evidence behind the call made Thu Oct 1 · 1:10 PM ET

We have not read the news for this player this week.

The evidence behind the call made Thu Oct 1 · 1:22 PM ET

We have not read the news for this player this week.

The evidence behind the call made Thu Oct 1 · 4:00 PM ET

We read the news; nothing was attributed.

The evidence behind the call made Thu Oct 1 · 5:00 PM ET

We read the news; nothing was attributed.

The evidence behind the call made Fri Oct 2 · 2:15 PM ET

We read the news; nothing was attributed.

The evidence behind the call made Fri Oct 2 · 5:00 PM ET

We read the news; nothing was attributed.

The evidence behind the call made Sat Oct 3 · 7:00 AM ET

We read the news; nothing was attributed.

The evidence behind the call made Sat Oct 3 · 12:00 PM ET

We read the news; nothing was attributed.

The evidence behind the call made Sat Oct 3 · 5:00 PM ET

We read the news; nothing was attributed.

The evidence behind the call made Sun Oct 4 · 7:00 AM ET

We read the news; nothing was attributed.

Role

Call history

The data behind this page — the timeline in words, every call and week on record, about him, and what this page does not show

Profile — as of week 4

RoleK1 · 0% snaps
Season2026 · 3 games through wk 3
Career2 seasons · 9 games before 2026
Injuries1 episode · last: hamstring, 2024 wk 13
Bioage 27.3 · 2 seasons' experience

Where the profile comes from

Built from: honors.db; nflverse injuries_2026.csv; medical.db; nflverse players.csv; profile.db; nflverse roster_2026.csv; nflverse roster_weekly_2026.csv; nflverse snap_counts_2026.csv; nflverse stats_player_week_2026.csv. Every number in it is one those sources hold.

nflverse injuries_2026.csv

About him

About himAs the record holds it
His rolea backup at placekicker — 0% of the snaps in his best week of 11
Listed on the depth chartfirst at placekicker
Snaps played0% a week on average over 11 weeks, 0% at his highest, 26% on special teams
Build6 ft 2 in · 201 lb
CollegeNotre Dame; University of South Florida
Draftedundrafted
Age25-28 at the season's start
Experience2 seasons

When this call was made, and when the world knew

  1. WrittenWe first said PLAY.
  2. PublicOur call became public when the week settled.
  3. KickoffKickoff.

How our call moved, earliest first

WhenLeadCallChance he playsBandOn what
Thu Oct 1 · 1:10 PM ET68 hPLAY87%EXPECTEDour call
Thu Oct 1 · 1:22 PM ET68 hPLAY87%EXPECTEDour call
Thu Oct 1 · 4:00 PM ET66 hPLAY92%EXPECTEDbefore his team said anything
Thu Oct 1 · 5:00 PM ET65 hPLAY92%EXPECTEDbefore his team said anything
Fri Oct 2 · 2:15 PM ET43 hPLAY92%EXPECTEDbefore his team said anything
Fri Oct 2 · 5:00 PM ET41 hPLAY92%EXPECTEDbefore his team said anything
Sat Oct 3 · 7:00 AM ET27 hPLAY92%EXPECTEDbefore his team said anything
Sat Oct 3 · 12:00 PM ET22 hPLAY92%EXPECTEDbefore his team said anything
Sat Oct 3 · 5:00 PM ET17 hPLAY92%EXPECTEDbefore his team said anything
Sun Oct 4 · 7:00 AM ET3 hPLAY92%EXPECTEDbefore his team said anything

10 calls in week 4, and the call never flipped between PLAY and SIT. Each lead time is the one that call actually had when it was written — never recounted from now. A call that changes is the record working: new evidence arrived and we said so, in public, before the game.

What would change this read

What would change this read
Final Friday/Saturday injury report designation (questionable vs none) for the London game
Whether the Colts elevated or signed a backup kicker during the week
Confirmation Shrader traveled to London and handled kicks in the final practice/walkthrough