Return2PLAi

Week 5 · 2026 season

We say who plays, days before the team does

Every player on this week's injury report gets a call from us — and we write it down, timestamped, before his team has announced anything. Nothing here can be edited afterwards. See how the calls have scored.

This page shows the calls from about a day before kickoff; clients see them from Wednesday.

19
calls of our own
18 / 1
play / sit
37 h
ahead of kickoff, on average
0
ruled out by their team

Who the teams cannot easily replace

Every player here is listed first or second at his position on his team's own published depth chart, and there is something to say about his availability. The order is that rank, then what the team has said, then the share of snaps he has actually played — every input is a fact somebody else published, so the same week always produces the same list.

6Baker Mayfield

TB · Quarterback

likely to play — our reading98% of snaps over 3 weeks

TB's starting quarterback, and we read him as likely to play. He has taken 98% of the snaps across 3 weeks.
our ranking of who matters this week · as of 2026-10-08 01:41

0DeMarvion Overshown

DAL · Left inside linebacker

a genuine coin flip — our reading74% of snaps over 1 week

DAL's starting left inside linebacker, and we read him as a genuine coin flip. He has taken 74% of the snaps across 1 week.
our ranking of who matters this week · as of 2026-10-08 01:41

21Benjamin Morrison

TB · Right cornerback

likely to play — our reading56% of snaps over 3 weeks

TB's starting right cornerback, and we read him as likely to play. He has taken 56% of the snaps across 3 weeks.
our ranking of who matters this week · as of 2026-10-08 01:41

4Chase McLaughlin

TB · Placekicker

likely to play — our reading0% of snaps over 4 weeks

TB's backup placekicker, and we read him as likely to play. He has taken 0% of the snaps across 4 weeks.
our ranking of who matters this week · as of 2026-10-08 01:41

2Cobie Durant

DAL · Left cornerback

a genuine coin flip — our reading62% of snaps over 2 weeks

DAL's starting left cornerback, and we read him as a genuine coin flip. He has taken 62% of the snaps across 2 weeks.
our ranking of who matters this week · as of 2026-10-08 01:41

8SirVocea Dennis

TB · Right inside linebacker

likely to play — our reading20% of snaps over 4 weeks

TB's rotational right inside linebacker, and we read him as likely to play. He has taken 20% of the snaps across 4 weeks.
our ranking of who matters this week · as of 2026-10-08 01:41

11Alijah Clark

DAL · Strong safety

likely to play — our reading12% of snaps over 4 weeks

DAL's rotational strong safety, and we read him as likely to play. He has taken 12% of the snaps across 4 weeks.
our ranking of who matters this week · as of 2026-10-08 01:41

67Drew Shelton

DAL · Left tackle

a genuine coin flip — our reading2% of snaps over 4 weeks

DAL's backup left tackle, and we read him as a genuine coin flip. He has taken 2% of the snaps across 4 weeks.
our ranking of who matters this week · as of 2026-10-08 01:41

73Tyler Smith

DAL · Left guard

likely to play — our reading

DAL's left guard, and we read him as likely to play.
our ranking of who matters this week · as of 2026-10-08 01:41

What we say

What we expect, before anyone has announced it — least certain first. Each call carries a band: a group of players we have scored the same way in the past, with the share of them who actually played. Only the two outer bands are decisive. How this works.

Our calls for week 5 — least certain first. Lead is how early we FIRST made the call shown, never recounted from now.
PlayerPosTeamOppInjuryCallBandLead
Cobie DurantCBDALTBHamstringPLAYCOIN FLIP37 h
Drew SheltonTDALTBHamstringSITCOIN FLIP37 h
DeMarvion OvershownLBDALTBHamstringPLAYCOIN FLIP37 h
Benjamin MorrisonCBTBDALQuadricepPLAYLIKELY37 h
Baker MayfieldQBTBDALThumbPLAYLIKELY37 h
SirVocea DennisLBTBDALAnklePLAYLIKELY37 h
Tyler SmithGDALTBThumbPLAYLIKELY37 h
Chase McLaughlinKTBDALGroinPLAYLIKELY37 h
Alijah ClarkSDALTBAnklePLAYLIKELY37 h
Ko KieftTETBDALElbowPLAY confidentEXPECTED37 h
James HoustonLBDALTBShoulderPLAY confidentEXPECTED37 h
Antoine Winfield Jr.STBDALRibPLAY confidentEXPECTED37 h
Joey Porter Jr.CBDALTBAnklePLAY confidentEXPECTED37 h
Tyler GoodsonRBDALTBAnklePLAY confidentEXPECTED37 h
Josiah TrotterLBTBDALKneePLAY confidentEXPECTED37 h
CeeDee LambWRDALTBThighPLAY confidentEXPECTED37 h
Malik HookerSDALTBForearmPLAY confidentEXPECTED37 h
Anthony NelsonLBTBDALIllnessPLAY confidentEXPECTED37 h
Rueben Bain Jr.LBTBDALGroinPLAY confidentEXPECTED37 h

What a call is not

A PLAY call means we expect him on the field, not that he is healthy. Of the calls that are ours rather than a team's announcement, almost none are scratches, and that is a property of the problem rather than a gap: at this base rate almost nothing moves a case far enough to call a scratch with confidence. How this works.