Return2PLAi
35

S · #35 · Washington Commanders · week 6 vs San Francisco 49ers · Mon Oct 19 · 8:15 PM ET

Percy Butler

  • ROLE in the rotation
  • CLASS 2022 · R4 P113
  • EXP 4 seasons
  • AGE 25-28
  • DEPTH FS3

As of week 6, Percy Butler was an SAF for WAS, age 26.3, 4 seasons of experience, drafted in round 4. In 2026 through week 5 he was listed at depth rank 2 on his club's depth chart; he had played 4 games on 12% of snaps. Before 2026 he played 66 games (postseason included) over 4 seasons. His injury history held 10 episodes (groin 2, hip 2, calf 1), 3 of them reaching OUT, 2 a repeat of an earlier site; the last was a concussion injury in 2026 week 4.

The full read

In short

How our call moved in week 6

  • our call, P(plays)
  • club report (public)

59% COIN FLIP → 59% COIN FLIP

Every call we wrote for him in week 6, earliest first, as written.

In short

Percy Butler is in the rotation at free safety for WAS — 29% of the snaps in his best week of 8. He has a hamstring injury. His team named him inactive in week 5. In week 6 he did not practise, then practised limited. His team has listed him Questionable. We called him PLAY in week 5 and he did not play.

The reader concurs · grade C

The sole written evidence is a Thursday 15 Oct report that the Commanders 'practiced without' Butler with a hamstring (P1) — a mid-week absence that is consistent with a limited-to-absent practice axis but contains no ruling-out or game-status language for Monday.

What the read cites

What was reportedSource
1“The Commanders also practiced without receiver Stefon Diggs and safeties Percy Butler and Tyler Owens, who are all dealing with hamstring injuries. Those guys could return to work later in the week.”Hogs Haven · 2026-10-15
The reader's full reasoning

The rest of the reading

The same report adds the hamstring group 'could return to work later in the week' (P1), which leans mildly toward availability rather than against it. Nothing in P1 contradicts the PLAY call, so I concur, though the record is thin: there is no Fri/Sat/Sun participation line and no designation filed.

15versions in week 6
13average, every player
54most for one player

How the call moved

COIN FLIP since Fri Oct 16 · 7:01 AM ET · 85 h before kickoff · 43 h before the club. Biggest move: 62% → 37%, Fri Oct 16 · 5:21 PM ET to Fri Oct 16 · 7:56 PM ET, with no club report in between.

Our call

Injury report

His team's word: Questionable

This is the TEAM'S OWN ANNOUNCEMENT, not a reading of ours. His team filed him on the injury report and we are restating it so the record is complete. There is nothing early about repeating an announcement — what we say ahead of one is on the week's page. Source: his team's published inactive list, on the day.

Practice in week 6

FriThu
LPdated Sat Oct 17DNPdated Sat Oct 17

Shape of the week: improving. Only days the publisher dated are shown; a day we could not date is left out until the nightly sweep stamps it. The shape is a fact, not a forecast.

Head start

  • His club's word
  • Kickoff

The evidence behind his current call

We read the news for this call. The quotes we found are not shown publicly.

Stats, with ranges — dot = his average, bar = his game range

  • Snap share10.3% range 0–29

    wk 1–10 · 8 games

Snaps by week — his larger of the offence and defence share

  1. 0%wk 1
  2. 0%wk 2
  3. 19%wk 3
  4. 29%wk 4
  5. 0%wk 6
  6. 0%wk 8
  7. 9%wk 9
  8. 25%wk 10

Missed while on the injury report

SeasonWeeks on the reportMissed while listed
202641

Only the weeks he was on the injury report with a recorded result — not every game of his career.

Medical history

WhenInjuryWeeks on a reportWorst status
2026 · wk 5hamstring2Out
2026 · wk 4concussion1Questionable
2026 · wk 3groin1—
2025 · wk 4hip2Out
2024 · wk 5groin3Questionable
2023 · wk 17wrist1Out
2023 · wk 16illness1Questionable
2023 · wk 9calf1Questionable
2023 · wk 4foot1Questionable
2022 · wk 17hip1Questionable
2022 · wk 5quad3Out

Every injury episode on file for him, as the record holds it.

Injury history by season · 11 episodes · 17 weeks on a report · same site more than once: groin ×2

  • ruled out
  • questionable
  • listed, and played

Each bar is one episode: the week it began and how many weeks he was on a report, coloured by the worst status.

The rest of his team's report in week 6

PlayerPosPracticeWhose wordCallChance he playsBand
Stefon DiggsWRLTDteam's wordQuestionable
Marcus MariotaQBDNPteam's wordOut
Laremy TunsilOTUNKteam's word—
Lucas PatrickGFULLteam's wordQuestionable
Austin EkelerRBLTDoursPLAY90%EXPECTED
Fabian MoreauCBLTDteam's wordOut
Jeremy McNicholsRBFULLteam's wordQuestionable
Jeremy ReavesSLTDoursPLAY90%EXPECTED
Isaac YiadomCBUNKteam's wordOut
Charles OmenihuDEDNPteam's wordOut
Terry McLaurinWRLTDoursPLAY92%EXPECTED
Javon KinlawDTLTDteam's wordQuestionable
K'Lavon ChaissonLBFULLoursPLAY97%EXPECTED
Rachaad WhiteRBLTDoursPLAY99%EXPECTED
Nick CrossSFULLteam's wordQuestionable
Treylon BurksWRLTDoursPLAY94%EXPECTED
Leo ChenalLBUNKteam's word—
Quan MartinSFULLoursPLAY89%EXPECTED
Jordan MageeLBLTDteam's wordQuestionable
Javontae Jean-BaptisteLBDNPteam's wordOut
Tyler OwensSLTDteam's wordQuestionable
Jer'Zhan NewtonDTUNKteam's word—
Jayden DanielsQBFULLoursPLAY95%EXPECTED
T.J. MaguranyangaLBUNKteam's wordOut
Jaylin LaneWRUNKteam's word—
Jacory Croskey-MerrittRBDNPteam's wordOut
Trey AmosCBFULLteam's wordQuestionable
Tanoa TogiaiGUNKteam's wordOut

The model reads the room: who else is out shifts what his own designation is worth.

The evidence behind his earlier calls

The evidence behind the call made Fri Oct 16 · 7:01 AM ET

We have not read the news for this player this week.

The evidence behind the call made Fri Oct 16 · 12:01 PM ET

We read the news; nothing was attributed.

The evidence behind the call made Fri Oct 16 · 3:49 PM ET

We read the news; nothing was attributed.

The evidence behind the call made Fri Oct 16 · 5:02 PM ET

We read the news; nothing was attributed.

The evidence behind the call made Fri Oct 16 · 5:21 PM ET

We read the news; nothing was attributed.

The evidence behind the call made Fri Oct 16 · 7:56 PM ET

We read the news; nothing was attributed.

The evidence behind the call made Sat Oct 17 · 7:02 AM ET

We read the news; nothing was attributed.

The evidence behind the call made Sat Oct 17 · 12:02 PM ET

We read the news; nothing was attributed.

The evidence behind the call made Sat Oct 17 · 5:01 PM ET

We read the news; nothing was attributed.

The evidence behind the call made Sun Oct 18 · 7:01 AM ET

We read the news; nothing was attributed.

The evidence behind the call made Sun Oct 18 · 12:02 PM ET

We read the news for this call. The quotes we found are not shown publicly.

The evidence behind the call made Sun Oct 18 · 5:05 PM ET

We read the news for this call. The quotes we found are not shown publicly.

The evidence behind the call made Mon Oct 19 · 7:01 AM ET

We read the news for this call. The quotes we found are not shown publicly.

The evidence behind the call made Mon Oct 19 · 12:02 PM ET

We read the news for this call. The quotes we found are not shown publicly.

The evidence behind the call made Mon Oct 19 · 5:01 PM ET

We read the news for this call. The quotes we found are not shown publicly.

The evidence behind the call made Mon Oct 19 · 6:59 PM ET

We read the news for this call. The quotes we found are not shown publicly.

Role

Call history

The data behind this page — the timeline in words, every call and week on record, about him, and what this page does not show

Profile — as of week 6

RoleSAF2 · 12% snaps
Season2026 · 4 games through wk 5
Career4 seasons · 66 games before 2026
Injuries10 episodes · last: concussion, 2026 wk 4
Bioage 26.3 · 4 seasons' experience · drafted round 4

Where the profile comes from

Built from: honors.db; nflverse injuries_2026.csv; medical.db; nflverse players.csv; profile.db; nflverse roster_2026.csv; nflverse roster_weekly_2026.csv; nflverse snap_counts_2026.csv; nflverse stats_player_week_2026.csv. Every number in it is one those sources hold.

nflverse injuries_2026.csv

About him

About himAs the record holds it
His rolein the rotation at free safety — 29% of the snaps in his best week of 8
Listed on the depth chartthird at free safety
Snaps played10% a week on average over 8 weeks, 29% at his highest, 64% on special teams
Build6 ft 0 in · 191 lb
CollegeLouisiana-Lafayette
Drafted2022, round 4 pick 113, by WAS
Age25-28 at the season's start
Experience4 seasons

When this call was made, and when the world knew

  1. Team reportHis team listed him Questionable.
  2. PublicHis team's word was public as soon as it was filed.
  3. KickoffKickoff.

How our call moved, earliest first

WhenLeadCallChance he playsBandOn what
Fri Oct 16 · 7:01 AM ET85 hPLAY59%COIN FLIPbefore his team said anything
Fri Oct 16 · 12:01 PM ET80 hPLAY59%COIN FLIPbefore his team said anything
Fri Oct 16 · 3:49 PM ET76 hPLAY59%COIN FLIPbefore his team said anything
Fri Oct 16 · 5:02 PM ET75 hPLAY62%COIN FLIPbefore his team said anything
Fri Oct 16 · 5:21 PM ET75 hPLAY62%COIN FLIPbefore his team said anything
Fri Oct 16 · 7:56 PM ET72 hSIT37%COIN FLIPafter his team's announcement
Sat Oct 17 · 7:02 AM ET61 hPLAY59%COIN FLIPafter his team's announcement
Sat Oct 17 · 12:02 PM ET56 hPLAY59%COIN FLIPafter his team's announcement
Sat Oct 17 · 5:01 PM ET51 hPLAY59%COIN FLIPafter his team's announcement
Sun Oct 18 · 7:01 AM ET37 hPLAY59%COIN FLIPafter his team's announcement
Sun Oct 18 · 12:02 PM ET32 hPLAY59%COIN FLIPafter his team's announcement
Sun Oct 18 · 5:05 PM ET27 hPLAY59%COIN FLIPafter his team's announcement
Mon Oct 19 · 7:01 AM ET13 hPLAY59%COIN FLIPafter his team's announcement
Mon Oct 19 · 12:02 PM ET8 hPLAY59%COIN FLIPafter his team's announcement
Mon Oct 19 · 5:01 PM ET3 hPLAY59%COIN FLIPafter his team's announcement
Mon Oct 19 · 6:59 PM ET1 hhis team's word——his team's published inactive list, on the day

15 calls in week 6, flipping between PLAY and SIT 2 times. Each lead time is the one that call actually had when it was written — never recounted from now. A call that changes is the record working: new evidence arrived and we said so, in public, before the game.

What would change this read

What would change this read
Commanders practice participation report naming Percy Butler for Fri 16, Sat 17 and Sun 18 Oct
Final game-status designation (Out/Doubtful/Questionable) on the injury report filed ahead of the Mon 19 Oct game
A Dan Quinn or team statement giving Butler's hamstring timeline for Monday
Availability of fellow safeties Tyler Owens (hamstring) and Nick Cross (illness) for Monday, which drives rotational need at safety
Any Monday inactives list for the 19 Oct game

We went and found out more

Rank 2 (listed second on his depth chart), 8 documents deep, because: llm_unsure. Fetched 8 of 8.

Last week, when he was on the report

Last weekHis team saidOur callPlayed
Week 5OutCOIN FLIPleans playno

Named inactive in week 5

The team's own list. We held it before kickoff, so it could have informed a call. Matched to him by his player id.